The Trepidations of Becoming an Editor …
Filed under: Writing
As we move forward with our Carnivah House anthology project, The Infinity Swords, I hope we do not encounter Unreason similar to the likes of another editor’s ghastly experience.
As a writer, I’ve been lucky. Most of the people I’ve encountered have seemed utterly reasonable, utterly friendly. Editors — even those who don’t buy my stuff — have for the most part been professional. Those readers I’ve heard from via email or forums or whatever have been very nice and generally enthusiastic. The other writers I’ve met online or worked with are a great bunch, even when disagreements arise over proper sonnet form or the merits of Tolkien’s work.
But now, I’m editing an anthology along with a couple of other people. Pretty soon, we’ll be reading submissions from gods-know how many people. Some of what we receive will be awesome, but some of it will be utter crap. As editors, we will have to crush some dreams.
We’ll do it as gently and professionally as we can, of course, but the dreams still get stomped upon. Those who have been in the short fiction trenches a while will read our rejections, react in whatever way works best for them, and then get on with their writerly lives.
Some will try sending us something else, just to prove they can sell to us. That’s cool. Some will send their story to another publisher, just to prove we were wrong. That’s cool, too. Some will read our advice and heed it, others will decide we’re full of crap and keep doing things their way. That, too, is cool.
But what about the new writers, the ones who haven’t been through the submissions furnace? Will they react like the crazed woman noted in the link above? Will they go off the deep end? Will the mental unbalance that prompts them to attempt writing fiction in the first place finally teeter over into Total Unholy Madness? Will they send us nasty email, burn voodoo dolls in our images, set baying werewolves on our trail?
I guess we’ll find out.
Just one note: Any writer who calls us on the phone, unbidden, to ask about their submission or to complain about a rejection or to tell us how gee-whiz wonderful their story is so could we please read it Right This Instant, will get an automatic lifetime-and-beyond ban from all Carnivah House productions. And we’ll burn voodoo dolls and sic our baying werewolves on you.
– Steve
Comments(8)
